Welcome to the Keuka Cove House
Hi, we’re Josh and Jeb! The Keuka Cove House is more than just a short-term rental — it’s our way of sharing the peace, joy, and beauty of Keuka Lake with you. Whether you’re here to unwind by the water, reconnect with family, or make new memories, we’re happy to welcome you into our little piece of paradise.
Meet the team
Josh Brubaker | Owner
I grew up in a small town in Andover, NY — even smaller than nearby Penn Yan — but some of my best memories were made on Keuka Lake. My grandparents and uncle had a place on the West Bluff, and summers here quickly became the highlight of my childhood.
Keuka Lake has always held a special place in my heart. Since college, I’ve often said that one day I’d love to own a home here, though I never imagined it would happen so soon. When the opportunity came to purchase what was once the historic Hart-Scott, I knew it was the chance to carry forward its legacy while creating something fresh for future guests.
That vision became the Keuka Cove House — a reimagined retreat that honors the property’s timeless charm while offering modern comforts and experiences. More than just a place to stay, this home represents my way of giving back to the lake that has given me so many memories, joy, and lifelong connections.
Whether you’re gathering with family, reconnecting with friends, or simply unwinding by the water, my hope is that the Keuka Cove House offers you the same sense of joy, peace, and belonging that Keuka Lake has always given me.
Jeb “Jebbers” brubaker | Security
Jeb was an unexpected gift. In August of 2024, my sister’s husband rescued a dog while traveling through Pennsylvania, and they eventually named her Rosie. To everyone’s surprise, Rosie was pregnant — and when her puppies arrived, I chose Jeb because he reminded me most of his mom. From the very beginning, he quickly stole my heart.
Rosie proudly serves as the Security Bark Officer at the Keuka Cove Inn just down the road, and when the same position became available here at the Keuka Cove House, she was quick to “recruit” her son to the team. Jeb takes his duties seriously, greeting visitors with tail wags and making sure every squirrel, chipmunk, and delivery driver knows the property is well protected.
When he’s off duty, Jeb can usually be found chasing sticks, napping in sunny spots, or sneaking belly rubs from guests. Equal parts loyal guard dog and lovable sidekick, he’s become an inseparable part of the Keuka Cove House family — and just like me, he’s always ready to welcome new friends to the lake.
Note: Jeb isn’t actually onsite or involved with your stay — but I had to give the guy a shout-out. He’s too good of a pup not to! 🐾
