THE KEUKA COVE HOUSE
REAL GUEST EXPERIENCES
From family gatherings to alumni weekends, guests love the space, privacy, historic character, and lakefront setting of the Keuka Cove House.
★★★★★
“The Pictures Don’t Do This Place Justice.”
“The pictures don’t do this place justice. It is immaculate and well laid out for a large group. We spent Thanksgiving here with my elderly parents, my family of 5 and my brother’s family of 5 and some significant others. It was a great time! The living area was big enough for us all and it was nice having 4 kitchens to draw from for serving-ware, plates and utensils.
I would highly recommend the Keuka Cove House and I’m keeping it in mind for future family gatherings as well as after reunion for getting my sorority sisters together. Book now to ENJOY!”
Google Review
Guest Reviews
Real feedback from guests who stayed, gathered, celebrated, and relaxed at the Keuka Cove House.
★★★★★
“This house is amazing!! Full of 19th century charm but with all the modern conveniences. There were plenty of comfortable beds and private bathrooms for each family. The kids had a riot playing hide ’n’ go seek in all the nooks and crannies. The view of Keuka Lake from the front porch and the kitchen window was so beautiful. We all agreed, Josh is the best host we’ve EVER encountered.”
Google Review
★★★★★
“Beautiful property with several spacious live in suites, a spacious back yard with amenities and a boat house and dock with lake access. A gem on Keuka Lake and a 5 minute drive to Penn Yan. Would definitely recommend.”
Google Review
★★★★★
“Beautiful, well kept older home. Spent 3 days there and wished it could have been more. House was big enough to accommodate all of my guests. Host was pleasant to work with. Highly recommend.”
Google Review
★★★★★
“We spent a long weekend at the Keuka Cove House and absolutely loved it. The fireplaces, both down by the water and up behind the house, made the evenings so peaceful. You can tell how much care went into restoring and maintaining this property. For being such an old home, everything is beautifully done and spotless.”
Google Review
★★★★★
“I’m a Keuka College alum and came back to visit with a few classmates for the weekend. We stayed at the Keuka Cove House and couldn’t have picked a better spot. It’s just a few minutes from campus, super clean, and had everything we needed to hang out, catch up, and relive some of the old days.”
Google Review
★★★★★
“Visited the Finger Lakes for some fall foliage and had the best time at the Keuka Cove House! The home is huge and comfortably fit our group of 16 without it ever feeling crowded. It’s PERFECT for big family gatherings.”
Google Review
★★★★★
“We made a trip up to the Finger Lakes for some wine tasting and had an incredible stay at the Keuka Cove House. The location is ideal, it feels quiet and tucked away for a peaceful getaway, yet you’re just seconds from Route 54, making it so easy to explore the nearby wineries and restaurants.”
Google Review
★★★★★
“We stayed here for 3 nights with a large group of 16, including kids, and it was a wonderful experience. There was plenty of space for everyone to sleep comfortably, and the separate units were perfect for those who wanted a bit more privacy. A special shoutout to Josh, who was the most responsive and helpful Airbnb host we’ve ever worked with.”
Google Review
★★★★★
“Whenever you rent a place for the first time you are not sure what to expect. Keuka Cove was everything we needed and more. A beautiful house on a beautiful piece of land. The beds are numerous and comfortable. We are 10 old friends, who get away once per year, and we all agreed that it was the best place we’ve stayed.”
Google Review
★★★★★
“Stayed in October with a group of friends. Great house in a great location. Enough room so everyone had their own space. Plenty of parking and easy access to lake front. Would definitely stay again.”
Google Review
★★★★★
“My friends and family meet every year for an annual vacation weekend. Josh went above and beyond to accommodate us just after purchasing the home. The home is a beautiful historic home with an amazing view of Keuka Lake! There was plenty of space with bedrooms to spare for a group of 10 plus 2 kids.”
Google Review
★★★★★
“My friends and I stayed at Josh’s place for a long weekend and I cannot recommend it enough. The house is gorgeous and interesting with more than enough room for our large group. The location is great — right across the street from the lake, with access to the lake, but still on a private lot with a private backyard and views of the lake.”
Google Review
★★★★★
“This house was awesome! We had 14 adults and had plenty of room. House has so much charm. Owner is awesome and very very responsive. We will definitely stay here again!”
Google Review
★★★★★
“This house was great we had a family trip here with multiple couples. Lots of bedrooms, lots of bathrooms, huge kitchen space. Also the units off to the side were great for some of our family that wanted their own space so everyone wasn’t standing on top of each other. Would stay here again.”
Google Review
★★★★★
“Stayed in Unit 2 and it was a perfect studio for a short stay. Lots of charm here and all the amenities you need to enjoy the lake if the weather were nice. Nice view of the lake to boot. Five minutes from downtown Penn Yan, which means you’re close to everything you need for the stay.”
Google Review
★★★★★
“I stayed at the Keuka Cove House from January to March when I needed a place on short notice, and it was a great experience. Josh was very welcoming, flexible, and made things easy. The space was clean, comfortable, and felt like my own little home. Highly recommend booking the Keuka Cove House.”
Google Review
Ready for Lake Time?
See why guests keep recommending the Keuka Cove House for family gatherings, group getaways, and private Keuka Lake stays.